Sunday, 27 September, 2026

Responding to Bill Weber: “Projection and Confession”

With Republicans, It’s Always “Projection” and “Confession”
Bill Weber’s recent whine about me claims that I am a “radical” because of my endorsement by the Working Families Party. He thinks that because a group endorses me, that means I must adopt every single one of their policy positions on every issue.
That’s both Projection and Confession. Why? Because Bill Weber himself is a “radical” – a hardcore right-wing Conservative who has a perfect 100% rating from the Conservative Party, which has all sorts of radical positions on choice, immigration, LGBTQIA+ issues, health care, and education.
How did he get that perfect rating? Hardcore conservative votes like these:
• Voting against the bipartisan Data Center Moratorium and common-sense policies to protect rate-payers and residents.
• Voting against the Equal Rights Amendment that provided protections against discrimination on ethnicity, national origin, age, disability, and sex.
• Voting against codifying the right to choice in the state constitution.
• Voting against “pay for delay” agreements that keep cheaper generic drugs off the market.
• Voting against restrictions on “Surveillance Pricing” by supermarkets, which jack up grocery prices for shoppers.
• Voting against taking away guns from suspected domestic abusers at the scene of a domestic violence incident.
In other words, in the eyes of the Conservative Party, he’s “perfect!”
So it’s all Projection and Confession.
“Projection” because he thinks I’m just like him. He’s a hardcore, radical extremist who backs his partisans 100% of the time, so he thinks I do the same.
And “Confession” because his accusations against me betray his belief that if you get an endorsement, then you’re adopting every position of that group – because that’s what he does!
Bill simply can’t conceive of someone who is an independent thinker who takes on each issue on its merits and sometimes legitimately disagrees with his party or the groups who support him.
For example, I don’t agree with “Defund the Police”. That was an unfortunate slogan to express the underlying concept that we should “let police be police,” relieving them of some of their "social work" responsibilities by putting more resources into public services and letting them focus on public safety and fighting crime. That’s why I hired the first social worker in Nyack history, working with Catholic Charities to assign someone to the village to help identify at-risk individuals and make proactive contact to reduce the “social work” burden on the police.
I also don’t believe in an absolute “No Cash Bail” position and would not have supported the original cashless bail legislation in 2019, which I think was poorly implemented. I believe the current version of the legislation is better, but still could be improved to incorporate considerations of public safety into the bail consideration.
That said, I agree with a lot of the positions of the WFP. They didn’t endorse me because I’ll be a “rubber stamp” for them – they endorsed me because I’m broadly aligned with their goals of a more equal society and building our economy from the roots up.
Most importantly, I have an open mind, to both people on my left and right. I’m willing to talk to people who disagree with me to hear them out and give them an opportunity to persuade me. And I’m not looking to get 100% ratings from anyone, or adopt wholesale issue positions from people who endorse me or contribute to my campaign. That’s Bill’s gig.
Finally, if Bill really thinks I’m a radical, let’s see him say it to my face, and defend his own right-wing record. Last week, I challenged him to four debates this October, one in each of the four towns in the District. Bill hasn’t responded.
I’ve already accepted debate invitations from Rockland Community College, Rockland News, Rockland Daily – basically, anyone who is interested in having a debate, I’m there. And I’m participating in the NAACP candidate forum on October 7.
I’ll debate Bill anytime, anywhere, about anything. But as far as I know, Bill has declined all those invitations. If he changes his mind on that, he should let me and the organizers know and we’ll get this going!
In the meantime, if Bill wants to see a radical who does whatever his bosses tell him, he should look in the mirror.
JR

 

 

 

Other Updates